Facts/syllabus: a public high school student delivered a speech at a school assembly nominating another student for a student office during the speech, he referred to his candidate using a graphic and explicit sexual metaphor. Bethel v fraser was the most cited precedent in a more recent supreme court case about student free speech rights called morse v frederick, a case that dealt with whether a student could hold up a sign across from school grounds saying “bong hits 4 jesus. Bethel school district v fraser , a timeline made with timetoast's free interactive timeline making software.
On april 26, 1983, respondent matthew n fraser, a student at bethel high school in pierce county, washington, delivered a speech nominating a fellow student for student elective office approximately 600 high school students, many of whom were 14. Bethel school district no 403 v fraser, case in which the us supreme court on july 7, 1986, ruled (7–2) that school officials did not violate a student’s free speech and due process rights when he was disciplined for making a lewd and vulgar speech at a school assembly in april 1983 matthew. Matthew n fraser was an outstanding student at bethel high school in pierce county, washington in april 1983, fraser prepared to give a speech at a school assembly.
Bethel v fraser free speech for kids 102 likes resource page on free speech for kids & teens - with input & perhaps with advice from former litigants. How can the answer be improved. Facts matthew fraser (plaintiff), a high school senior was suspended for three days by the bethel school district (defendant) after he gave a lewd speech full of sexual innuendos in front of six hundred students at a school assembly. Outlines the case of bethel school district n 403 v fraser in which the supreme court overturned the lower court decisions and recognized that schools have an interest in protecting minors from exposure to vulgar and offensive spoken language. Facts: on april 26, 1983, matthew fraser, a student at bethel high school in pierce county, washington, delivered the following speech nominating a fellow student for student elective office: i know a man who is firm - he's firm in his pants, he's firm in his shirt, his character is firm - but most.
Case: bethel v fraser year: 1986 result: 7-2, favor bethel high school related constitutional issue/amendment: amendment 1: speech, press, and assembly civil rights or civil liberties: civil liberties precedent: the court found that it was appropriate for the school to prohibit the use of offensive and sexual language the court further. The fourteenth amendment for brown v board of ed, or the fourth amendment for riley v california) students can discuss and predict the outcome after the first or second slide before revealing results on the third slide. Fraser, students are not allowed to have the same latitude in offensive good morning class man fuck this shit because of the court case bethel v fraser, students are not allowed to have the same latitude in offensive. Description a discussion about the supreme court case bethel school district v fraser, and the free speech rights of students. At bethel high school in pierce county, washington, senior student matthew fraser used a series of sexual double entendres in a speech that nominated one of his classmates for the position of associated student body vice president.
This case also conflicted with the court's ruling in tinker v des moines des moines the court addressed this issue when it said that it was sexual speech rather than political speech in tinker. Mathew fraser, a senior at bethel high school in bethel, washington, spoke to a school assembly to nominate a classmate for an office in student government his speech was filled with sexual references and innuendos, but it contained no obscenities. Bethel v fraser (1986) summary as the school year comes to a close and students are giving student government speeches and commencement addresses, we spotlight the landmark student expression case bethel vfraser (1986) in this case, the court considered whether the first amendment protected a student-government nomination. Hazelwood v kuhlmeier & bethel v fraser students will/will be able to read case summaries of two supreme court cases about students’ rights and determine whether students’ rights to free speech had been violated.
At a school assembly of approximately 600 students, matthew fraser made a speech nominating a fellow student for elective office during his speech, he used somewhat of a sexual metaphor to promote the candidacy of his friend the school enforced a rule prohibiting conduct which substantially interferes with the educational process. Bethel school district v fraser, 478 us 675 (1986) the supreme court overturned the ninth circuit court of appeals ruling, citing that the school did have the authority to punish students who committed lewd and indecent acts, but not necessarily obscene speech at school assemblies this is specific to public schools. Audio transcription for oral argument - march 03, 1986 in bethel school district no 403 v fraser william a coats: the vagueness argument is a due process argument that says the rule is excessively vague, and that is an issue that is before the court. Bethel school district v fraser (1986): situation: a student gave a 2-minute campaign speech during a school-sponsored assembly he used no four-letter words, but he did use sexual innuendo to describe a candidate for student government office.
Summary of bethel school district v fraser, us supreme court (1985) petitioner: bethel school district respondent: fraser the respondent was a student in bethel high school and he delivered a speech during a school assembly which was full of sexual metaphorsthe respondent was suspended for 2 days and he was prohibited from. Bethel school district v fraser 1986 censorship of expression in public high schools mathew fraser presented a speech in school for his friend in an upcoming class election the speech consisted of numerous sexual innuendos, mostly in reference to his friends sexual prowess bethel school district suspended fraser from school for three.
Matthew fraser was suspended from bethel high school in april 1983 the previous day, fraser had given a speech made for nominating a fellow student for the student government in front of the 600 students who attended the school. Bethel school district v fraser melissa fernandez block 2 citation page “bethel school district no 403 v fraser” the oyez project at iit chicago-kent college of law 10 september 2014. Supreme court cases project nicholas schultz block: 2 case name and issue: bethel v fraser on april 26, 1983, mathew n fraser, a student at bethel high school in pierce county, washington, delivered a speech nominating a.